Thursday, August 04, 2005

"Londoners not helpful" shock

Despite my rather sardonic headline, I actually am shocked by this report. I was shocked enough when I first heard the story of how a man was stabbed to death on the bus, simply for attempting to stop another passenger throwing chips at his girlfriend - I admit, the take-home message for me was, tell Beloved not to interfere in strangers' bad behaviour*.

But that was one, crazy guy doing one, crazy thing. To read that the whole bus full of non-crazy passengers simply stood by - let the man die, declined to get involved in basic first aid - that shocks me deeply.

The question of what I would have done is, obviously, unanswerable. I also know that this is not necessarily the standard response. My friend Pip was once in a tube carriage when an old man appeared to die, right in front of her, and the other passengers leapt into action. But maybe that was less threatening. Less bloody. Less close to the bone when the city is after all feeling rather vulnerable.

Anyway it sucks.

I didn't say I had any profound insights to offer.

_____
* There is a lot of appalling behaviour on London public transport, most of it from schoolchildren. It's almost incomprehensible to many South Africans - used, as we are, to a far more oldfashioned approach to discipline - how little authority figures step in to control misbehaviour (usually because they are not allowed). As an example, Beloved was once on a bus where two groups of kids got into a fight. The driver stopped the bus; the conductor and all non-combatant passengers got off and simply waited for them to get over it.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Yeah. Fantastic display of humanity. Reminds me of this story that happened some time ago here in the City of Gold...aml :-(

JOHANNESBURG
'Heartless' paramedics to be probed
Posted Mon, 04 Oct 2004

An investigation into the actions of two emergency workers who allegedly left a homeless man to die in the streets of Johannesburg is underway, the Health Professions Council of SA (HPCSA) said on Monday.

The council said it extremely concerned about the incident.

"All practitioners registered with the HPCSA are bound by a code for ethical and professional behaviour towards their patients and clients," it said in a statement.

Paramedics were called out to attend to a homeless man who was lying sick in the gutter in central Johannesburg on September 21.

"Too dirty" to transport in ambulance

When the Emergency Management Services workers arrived, they reportedly gave the man a cursory examination, but refused to transport him in their ambulance because he was too dirty.

"I pleaded with the two guys to take him to hospital, but they said he wasn't sick, just dirty. The old man was shivering and groaning. He was in pain," security guard Ambrose Dudula told the press at the time.

The man was found dead the next morning and taken to the mortuary, said police spokesperson Superintendent Chris Wilken.

"We would like to urge patients to assist us in exposing emergency care practitioners who make themselves guilty of malpractice or unprofessional conduct," said Lloyd Christopher, chairman of the Professional Board for Emergency Care Practitioners.

Christopher said on Monday that patients could complain to the HPCSA about incompetence, insufficient care, improper conduct, racial discrimination, and rude behaviour. SAPA

glo said...

In my psychology classes, they would discuss this phenomenon. I never did understand it, but I know it happens.

A girl in NY was raped and murdered on the front steps of her apartment - a time frame of 45 minutes with more than 100 witnesses - and no one even called the police.

It's sick. And distressing.